Side Order of Italian Sausage

$6.00

Out of stock

Two Italian sausages. Perfect addition to any meal.

Side Order of Meatballs

$6.00

Out of stock

Mike's homemade meatballs. Choose 4 or 8 pieces.

Cheesy Garlic Bread

$8.95

Out of stock

Toasted garlic bread topped with melted mozzarella. Served with marinara sauce.

Garlic Knots

$8.95

Out of stock

Eight garlic knots brushed with garlic butter and herbs. Served with marinara.

Onion Rings

$6.95

Out of stock

Thick-cut onion rings, breaded and fried to crispy perfection.

Chili Cheese Fries

$8.95

Out of stock

French fries loaded with chili and melted cheese. A meal in itself.

French Fries

$6.95

Out of stock

Crispy golden French fries. Perfect side or snack.

Chicken Tenders with Fries

$10.95

Out of stock

4 Crispy chicken tenders made fresh with fries.

Chicken Tenders

$9.95

Out of stock

Crispy chicken tenders made fresh.

Bruschetta

$11.95

Out of stock

Four pieces of garlic toast topped with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, balsamic glaze and olive oil.

Mozzarella Sticks

$8.95

Out of stock

Jalapeño Poppers

$8.95

Out of stock

Fried Mushrooms

$8.95

Out of stock

Side Marinara

$2.00

Out of stock

Side Ranch 4oz

$1.00

Out of stock

Side of Meat Sauce

$4.00

Out of stock

New York Style Pizza

$13.95

Out of stock

Authentic New York thin-crust pizza the way Mike’s been making it for 35 years. Not too much sauce, not too much cheese—perfectly balanced with just the right crunch and chew. Build your own with our 20+ toppings.

One Topping New York Style Pizza

$15.95

Out of stock

Authentic New York thin-crust pizza the way Mike’s been making it for 35 years. Not too much sauce, not too much cheese—perfectly balanced with just the right crunch and chew. Build your own with our 25+ toppings.

Two Toppings New York Style Pizza

$15.95

Out of stock

Authentic New York thin-crust pizza the way Mike’s been making it for 35 years. Not too much sauce, not too much cheese—perfectly balanced with just the right crunch and chew. Build your own with our 25+ toppings.

Three Toppings New York Style Pizza

$19.95

Out of stock

Authentic New York thin-crust pizza the way Mike’s been making it for 35 years. Not too much sauce, not too much cheese—perfectly balanced with just the right crunch and chew. Build your own with our 25+ toppings.

Lasagna Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Pasta noodles, sauce, mozzarella, ricotta, meatballs, and sausage. Lasagna on a pizza—seriously. This is exactly what it sounds like—lasagna on a pizza. We put pasta noodles, marinara sauce, mozzarella, ricotta cheese, meatballs, and Italian sausage on our pizza crust. Sounds crazy? Sure. Does it work? Absolutely. This is one of our most unique pizzas and customers either need to try it or they already love it. Only at Wise Guys will you find lasagna on a pizza. Because why not? Toppings: – Pasta Noodles – Marinara Sauce – Mozzarella Cheese – Ricotta Cheese – Homemade Meatballs – Italian Sausage

Margherita Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, and fresh tomato. The classic Italian pizza in its purest form. The classic Italian pizza that started it all. Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil leaves, and fresh tomato slices on our thin crust with a light sauce. Named after Queen Margherita of Italy, this pizza celebrates simple, quality ingredients. The colors even match the Italian flag—red tomatoes, white mozzarella, and green basil. This is pizza in its purest, most traditional form. Ingredients: – Fresh Mozzarella – Fresh Basil – Fresh Tomatoes – Light Sauce – Olive Oil

Veggie Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Bell peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms. Classic veggie combination. Our classic vegetarian option with the four most popular veggie toppings: bell peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms on our thin crust with mozzarella. Simple, satisfying, and perfect for vegetarians or anyone looking for a lighter pizza option. Vegetables: – Bell Peppers – Onions – Black Olives – Mushrooms – Mozzarella Cheese

4 Cheese Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Mozzarella, provolone, feta, and parmesan. A cheese lover’s dream. For those who believe you can never have too much cheese. We combine four premium cheeses—mozzarella, provolone, feta, and parmesan—on our thin crust with a light sauce. Each cheese brings its own character: mozzarella for stretch, provolone for smoothness, feta for tang, and parmesan for that sharp finish. Cheeses: – Mozzarella – Provolone – Feta – Parmesan

White Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Ricotta, mozzarella, provolone, and garlic. One of Mike’s top 3 signature pies—no sauce, all flavor. One of Mike’s three signature pizzas and a customer favorite for over 35 years. No tomato sauce here—just ricotta cheese, mozzarella, provolone, and fresh garlic on our perfect thin crust. This pizza proves you don’t need sauce for amazing flavor. The combination of three cheeses and garlic creates a rich, creamy taste that keeps customers coming back. Mike’s been perfecting this recipe since his days at Arthur Avenue Imports. This is authentic New York white pizza done right. Ingredients: – Ricotta Cheese – Mozzarella Cheese – Provolone Cheese – Fresh Garlic – Olive Oil

Hawaiian Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Ham, pineapple, and mozzarella. The classic combination that people either love or debate. The classic controversial combination—and we don’t judge. Ham and pineapple with mozzarella cheese on our thin crust. Sweet pineapple balances the savory ham for a unique flavor profile. You either love it or you haven’t tried it yet. Toppings: – Ham – Pineapple – Mozzarella Cheese

Gourmet Veggie Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Eggplant, spinach, peppers, onions, olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, roasted red peppers, and mozzarella. Loaded with fresh vegetables. Our most loaded vegetarian option. We pile on eggplant, fresh spinach, bell peppers, onions, black olives, mushrooms, fresh tomatoes, roasted red peppers, and mozzarella cheese. This isn’t your basic veggie pizza—it’s a gourmet combination of fresh vegetables that even meat lovers appreciate. Every bite is packed with flavor. Vegetables Included: – Eggplant – Fresh Spinach – Bell Peppers – Onions – Black Olives – Mushrooms – Fresh Tomatoes – Roasted Red Peppers – Mozzarella Cheese

Steak BBQ Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Your choice of steak, grilled chicken, or combo, with bacon, onions, BBQ sauce, and mozzarella. Choose your protein—steak, grilled chicken breast, or get both with the combo. We add bacon, sautéed onions, BBQ sauce, and mozzarella cheese. This pizza brings sweet and smoky BBQ flavor to every bite. The combo option is customer favorite for those who can’t decide. Shaved rib eye steak. All come with: – Bacon – Onions – BBQ Sauce – Mozzarella Cheese

Chicken BBQ Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Your choice of steak, grilled chicken, or combo, with bacon, onions, BBQ sauce, and mozzarella. Choose your protein—steak, grilled chicken breast, or get both with the combo. We add bacon, sautéed onions, BBQ sauce, and mozzarella cheese. This pizza brings sweet and smoky BBQ flavor to every bite. The combo option is customer favorite for those who can’t decide. Grilled chicken breast. All come with: – Bacon – Onions – BBQ Sauce – Mozzarella Cheese

Steak & Chicken BBQ Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Your choice of steak, grilled chicken, or combo, with bacon, onions, BBQ sauce, and mozzarella. Choose your protein—steak, grilled chicken breast, or get both with the combo. We add bacon, sautéed onions, BBQ sauce, and mozzarella cheese. This pizza brings sweet and smoky BBQ flavor to every bite. The combo option is customer favorite for those who can’t decide. Both steak and chicken. All come with: – Bacon – Onions – BBQ Sauce – Mozzarella Cheese

Meat Lovers Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Sausage, ham, bacon, pepperoni, meatballs, mozzarella, and provolone. For serious meat lovers. This one’s for the carnivores. We load up our thin crust with Italian sausage, ham, bacon, pepperoni, meatballs, mozzarella, and provolone cheese. No vegetables here—just quality meats and cheese on Mike’s perfect crust. If you love meat, this is your pizza. Meats Included: – Italian Sausage – Ham – Bacon – Pepperoni – Homemade Meatballs – Mozzarella Cheese – Provolone Cheese

Italian Deli Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni, mozzarella, and provolone. Like our famous Italian sub on a pizza. This pizza tastes like you walked into an authentic Italian deli. We pile on ham, Genoa salami, capicola, pepperoni, mozzarella, and provolone—the same quality meats we use in our famous Wise Guy Combo sub. Mike knows Italian deli meats—he grew up working in his family’s deli. This pizza brings that authentic deli flavor to every slice. Toppings: – Ham – Genoa Salami – Capicola – Pepperoni – Mozzarella Cheese – Provolone Cheese

Philly Steak Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Steak, peppers, onions, mushrooms, mozzarella, and provolone. A Philly cheesesteak on a pizza. Why choose between a Philly cheesesteak and pizza when you can have both? We load our thin crust with shaved steak, sautéed peppers, onions, mushrooms, mozzarella, and provolone cheese. This pizza brings together two American classics in one delicious pie. Toppings: – Shaved Rib Eye Steak – Green Peppers – Onions – Mushrooms – Mozzarella Cheese – Provolone Cheese

The Greek Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Feta cheese, tomatoes, onions, salami, ham, Greek olives, and mozzarella. A Mediterranean favorite. A Mediterranean twist on New York pizza. We top our thin crust with feta cheese, fresh tomatoes, red onions, salami, ham, authentic Greek olives, and mozzarella. Perfect for anyone who loves bold, tangy flavors. The feta and Greek olives give this pizza a unique character you won’t find anywhere else. Toppings: – Feta Cheese – Fresh Tomatoes – Red Onions – Salami – Ham – Greek Olives – Mozzarella Cheese

Deluxe Pizza

$18.95

Out of stock

Everything but the kitchen sink! Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, bacon, onions, green peppers, olives, and extra cheese. One of Mike’s top 3 signature pies. This is one of Mike’s three signature pizzas and a customer favorite for good reason. We pile on pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, bacon, onions, green peppers, black olives, and extra cheese on our perfect thin crust. When you can’t decide on toppings, get them all. This is the pie that keeps customers coming back week after week. Toppings Included: – Pepperoni – Italian Sausage – Mushrooms – Bacon – Onions – Green Peppers – Black Olives – Extra Mozzarella Cheese

Buffalo Chicken Ranch

$18.95

Out of stock

Our delicious New York style pizza with ranch as the base for the sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese, buffalo chicken, bacon and onions.

Antipasto

$13.95

Out of stock

Caprese Salad

$13.95

Out of stock

Grilled Chicken Caesar

$13.95

Out of stock

Greek Salad

$13.95

Out of stock

Tossed Salad

$12.95

Out of stock

Jumbo Wings

$11.95

Out of stock

Jumbo wings served with blue cheese or ranch, carrots and celery. Choose your quantity and flavor from 11 signature sauces.

Stromboli

$13.95

Out of stock

Stuffed with pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, and mozzarella cheese. Served with marinara sauce.

Calzone

$13.95

Out of stock

Stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella cheese, served with marinara sauce. Customize with your favorite toppings.

Pin Wheels

$12.95

Out of stock

Rolled pizza with pepperoni, sauce, and your choice of any 2 toppings. Available in 4 or 8 rolls.

Philly Cheese Sub

$9.95

Out of stock

Authentic Philly-style steak sub with sautéed onions, peppers & mushrooms on a toasted hero. Our Philly Cheese Steak Sub features thinly sliced rib eye steak, grilled to perfection with sautéed onions, peppers, and mushrooms. Topped with melted cheese and served on a toasted hero roll. A classic from the Home of the Famous Goodfellas menu—made the way Mike learned in New York.

The Wise Guy Combo Sub

$9.95

Out of stock

Mike’s signature Italian combo loaded with ham, ham cappy, genoa salami, pepperoni, provolone, and all the fixings. The Wise Guy Combo is Mike’s signature creation—a true Italian-American sub loaded with ham, ham cappy, genoa salami, pepperoni, and provolone cheese. Finished with fresh lettuce, tomato, onion, roasted red peppers, oil & vinegar on a toasted hero. This is the sub that started it all, inspired by the classic Italian combos from Mike’s days in New York. If you want to taste what Wise Guys is all about, this is it.

The Cousin Vinnie Sub

$9.95

Out of stock

Fried eggplant with roasted red peppers and fresh mozzarella, toasted on a garlic hero. The Cousin Vinnie features crispy fried eggplant layered with sweet roasted red peppers and fresh mozzarella cheese, all toasted on a garlic-rubbed hero roll. A vegetarian favorite that proves you don’t need meat to make a satisfying Italian sub. Named after the classic character, this one’s for anyone who appreciates good taste.

The Godfather Sub

$9.95

Out of stock

Grilled chicken with Italian dressing, sautéed onions, and fresh mozzarella, toasted on a garlic hero. The Godfather is a sub you can’t refuse. Tender grilled chicken tossed in Italian dressing, topped with sautéed onions and fresh mozzarella, all served on a toasted garlic hero. One of Mike’s signature creations that brings together simple ingredients done right. The kind of sub that makes an offer your taste buds won’t refuse.

The Wanna Be Sub

$9.95

Out of stock

Breaded chicken cutlet with pepper jack cheese, bacon, hot peppers, lettuce and ranch dressing on a toasted hero. The Wanna Be brings the heat with a crispy breaded chicken cutlet topped with melted pepper jack cheese, crispy bacon, spicy hot peppers, fresh lettuce, and cool ranch dressing on a toasted hero. This one’s got attitude—for those who think they can handle a little spice with their sandwich.

Chicken Philly Sub

$9.95

Out of stock

Chicken Philly with onions, peppers, and mushrooms in your choice of 8 flavors. The famous Goodfellas favorite. Our most customizable sub. Chicken Philly with sautéed onions, peppers, and mushrooms—but here’s the twist: choose from 8 different flavors. From the classic Original to Cajun, BBQ, Teriyaki, and more, you can customize this sub to your taste. This flexibility is what made the Goodfellas location famous.

Sausage & Peppers Hero

$9.95

Out of stock

Italian sausage with sautéed green peppers and onions on a toasted hero roll. Italian sausage grilled to perfection with sautéed green peppers and onions. Served on a toasted hero roll. This is street fair food at its finest. The sausage is juicy, the peppers and onions are sweet and caramelized, and it all comes together on a toasted roll.

Chicken Cutlet Parm Hero

$9.95

Out of stock

Breaded chicken cutlet covered in marinara sauce and melted mozzarella on a toasted hero roll. Breaded chicken cutlet, fried until golden and crispy, covered in marinara sauce and topped with melted mozzarella cheese. Served on a toasted hero roll. One of our most popular sandwiches. The chicken is tender, the breading is crispy, and the combination with sauce and cheese never gets old.

Eggplant Parm Hero

$9.95

Out of stock

Breaded eggplant covered in marinara sauce and melted mozzarella on a toasted hero roll. Breaded eggplant slices, fried until golden, covered in marinara sauce and topped with melted mozzarella cheese. Served on a toasted hero roll. A perfect vegetarian option that doesn’t sacrifice flavor. The eggplant is tender inside with a crispy coating, and the combination with sauce and cheese is classic Italian.

Meatball Parm Hero

$9.95

Out of stock

Homemade meatballs covered in marinara sauce and melted mozzarella on a toasted hero roll. Our homemade meatballs—made fresh daily using Mike’s family recipe from his uncle Tommy’s deli—covered in marinara sauce and topped with melted mozzarella cheese. Served on a toasted hero roll. This is classic Italian comfort food. The meatballs are tender, the sauce is flavorful, and the cheese is melted to perfection. This isn’t just a sandwich—it’s a family tradition.

3 Cheese Burger

$13.95

Out of stock

Half-pound burger topped with melted Swiss, provolone & muenster cheese.

BBQ Bacon Cheese Burger

$13.95

Out of stock

Half-pound burger topped with melted cheddar cheese, crispy bacon & BBQ sauce.

Classic Hamburger

$13.95

Out of stock

Half-pound burger with lettuce, tomato & red onion.

Alpine Swiss Burger

$13.95

Out of stock

Half-pound burger topped with sautéed mushrooms, onions & melted Swiss cheese.

Spaghetti

$10.95

Out of stock

Spaghetti with marinara sauce.

Tortellini Alfredo

$12.95

Out of stock

Cheese tortellini in creamy Alfredo sauce. Includes side salad & garlic knots.

Cheese Ravioli

$12.95

Out of stock

Topped with marinara. Includes side salad & garlic knots. Choose your style: cheese ravioli filled with creamy ricotta, or meat ravioli with a savory beef filling. Both are served with marinara sauce.

Meat Ravioli

$12.95

Out of stock

Topped with marinara. Includes side salad & garlic knots. Choose your style: cheese ravioli filled with creamy ricotta, or meat ravioli with a savory beef filling. Both are served with marinara sauce.

Baked Ziti

$12.95

Out of stock

Ziti pasta baked with ricotta, mozzarella & marinara sauce.

Eggplant Parm & Pasta

$14.95

Out of stock

Breaded eggplant topped with marinara and melted mozzarella, served with pasta.

Stuffed Shells

$12.95

Out of stock

Jumbo pasta shells stuffed with ricotta, topped with marinara & mozzarella.

Lasagna

$14.95

Out of stock

Homemade lasagna served with a side of pasta.

Chicken Cutlet Parm Dinner

$14.95

Out of stock

Breaded chicken cutlet topped with marinara and melted mozzarella.

Eggplant Rollatini & Pasta

$14.95

Out of stock

Tiramisu

$6.95

Out of stock

Classic Italian tiramisu with espresso-soaked ladyfingers & mascarpone. Per slice.

Cheesecake

$4.95

Out of stock

Classic New York-style cheesecake. Per slice.

Cannoli

$5.95

Out of stock

Classic Italian cannoli with sweet ricotta filling. Per piece.

Chocolate Cannoli

$6.95

Out of stock

Cannoli with chocolate-infused ricotta filling. Per piece.

Toasted Almond Cheesecake

$6.95

Out of stock

Creamy cheesecake with toasted almond topping. Per slice.

Manhattan Special Coffee Soda

$3.25

Out of stock

Classic New York coffee soda—a Brooklyn original since 1895.

Water

$2.00

Out of stock

Cold bottled water.

Soda

$2.69

Out of stock

Pepsi & Coke products available.